Reconciliation is a legislative process of the "United States Senate intended to allow passage of a budget bill not subject to "filibuster in the Senate. Reconciliation rules prohibit debate to exceed twenty hours under "Senate rules. Reconciliation also exists in the "United States House of Representatives. However, because the House regularly passes rules that constrain debate and amendments, the process has had a less significant impact on that body.
The process was created from the "Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and first used in 1980. The reconciliation rule allows tax, spending, and debt limit adjustments. However, larger policy change are limited due to the Byrd Rule, named after Democratic Senator "Robert Byrd, after an amendment added in 1990. The Byrd Rule prevents using reconciliation bills that include language "extraneous" to the budget.
One or multiple reconciliation bills can be passed in a given year with respect to topics of either spending, revenues, or debt limits. As an example, if a reconciliation bill impacts both spending and revenues, no further reconciliation on these topics can occur afterward since the first reconciliation bill addresses both of these. Reconciliation may only occur once for each topic per year unless Congress passes a second budget resolution.
The reconciliation process arose from the "Congressional Budget Act of 1974. Over time, it has developed into a procedure for implementing some policy decisions and assumptions embraced in a budget resolution in a way that was unforeseen when the Budget Act was enacted. Under the original design of the Budget Act, reconciliation had a fairly narrow purpose: it was expected to be used together with the second budget resolution adopted in the fall, was to apply to a single fiscal year, and be directed primarily at spending and revenue legislation acted on between the adoption of the first and second budget resolutions.
Although reconciliation was originally understood to be for the purpose of either reducing deficits or increasing surpluses, the language of the 1974 act refers only to "changes" in revenue and spending amounts, not specifically to increases or decreases. Per former "Parliamentarian of the Senate "Robert Dove,
|“||[reconciliation] was never used for that purpose. But in 1975, just a year after it had passed, a very canny Senate committee chairman, "Russell Long of Louisiana, came into the Parliamentarian's Office, and he kept having trouble with his tax bills because of the Senate rules. People were offering amendments to them that he didn't like. They were debating them at length, and he didn't like that. And he saw in the Budget Act a way of getting around those pesky little problems. And he convinced the Parliamentarian at the time—I was the assistant—that the very first use of reconciliation should be to protect his tax cut bill.||”|
Congress has used the procedure to enact omnibus budget bills, first in 1980. Between 1980 and 2009, 17 of 23 reconciliation bills have been signed into law by Republican presidents (a Republican was president for 20 of those 29 years). Since 1980, reconciliation has been used nine times when Republicans controlled both the House and the Senate, six times when Democrats controlled both the House and the Senate, one time when the Democrats controlled the Senate and the Republicans the House, and seven times when the Republicans controlled the Senate and the Democrats controlled the House. Reconciliation has been used at least once nominally for a non-budgetary purpose (for example, see the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007, when a Republican was president and the Democrats controlled Congress). The "1986 Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985 (COBRA) contained some health care provisions.
The Byrd Rule (as described below) was adopted in 1985 and amended in 1990. Its main effect has been to prohibit the use of reconciliation for provisions that would increase the deficit beyond 10 years after the reconciliation measure. The removal of such provisions has been described as a "Byrd Bath."
Congress used reconciliation to enact President "Bill Clinton's 1993 (fiscal year 1994) budget. (See Pub.L. 103–66, 107 "Stat. 312.) Clinton wanted to use reconciliation to pass his "1993 health care plan, but Senator "Robert Byrd insisted that the health care plan was out of bounds for a process that is theoretically about budgets.["citation needed]
In 1997, Congress passed the "Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 which was a reconciliation bill that reduced taxes and hence increased the deficit, but was paired with the "Balanced Budget Act of 1997 (H.R. 2014 and H.R. 2015 respectively), each signed by President Clinton. In 1999, the Congress for the first time used reconciliation to pass legislation that would increase deficits without a companion bill that reduced spending (thereby ignoring the bill from 1975): the Taxpayer Refund and Relief Act 1999. This act was passed when the Government was expected to run large surpluses. It was subsequently vetoed by President "Bill Clinton. A similar situation happened in 2000, when the Senate again used reconciliation to pass the Marriage Tax Relief Reconciliation Act 2000, which was also vetoed by Clinton. At the time, the use of the reconciliation procedure to pass such bills was controversial.
During the administration of President "George W. Bush, Congress used reconciliation to enact three major tax cuts. These tax cuts were set to lapse after 10 years to fulfill the requirements of the Byrd Rule which prohibits legislation that increases the deficit after the time period covered by the budget resolution (section 313 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974).
The "Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (H.R. 4872) is a reconciliation bill passed by the "111th United States Congress to make changes to the "Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. It was signed into law by President "Barack Obama on March 30, 2010. In the years following the passage of the PPACA, several Republicans proposed using reconciliation to repeal major parts of the act. In 2016, Republicans passed a bill via reconciliation to undo parts of ACA, although the bill was vetoed by President "Barack Obama.
The "American Health Care Act of 2017 is an ACA replacement bill that GOP leaders have intended to pass using reconciliation. The bill was withdrawn before March 24, 2017, but later passed in a vote by the House by a vote of 217-213 on May 3, 2017. Since the "Republican majority 115th Senate does not have a 60-member "filibuster proof majority in the U.S. Senate (with only a 52-member simple majority), reconciliation would be one way to repeal the Affordable Care Act without being filibustered. Senate "minority leader "Chuck Schumer has stated that he believes that a "AHCA reconciliation vote would violate the terms of the Byrd Rule which requires reconciliation bills to deal strictly with budget matters. Senator "Roy Blunt, vice chairman of the "Senate Republican Conference, has stated that overruling the Senate parliamentarian on a Byrd Rule ruling would "virtually guarantee that the GOP health-care law would be challenged in court" since the rule is incorporated into the Budget Act itself. After "scoring" by the "Congressional Budget Office on May 24, 2017, the House bill is expected to reduce deficits by $119 billion over a 10 year period, which therefore qualifies it for a simple majority vote. Such rules would dictate that any bill that failed to provide substantial budget deficit reduction would not quality under reconciliation and would be subject to filibuster.
To trigger the reconciliation process, Congress passes a "concurrent resolution on the budget instructing one or more committees to report changes in law affecting the budget by a certain date. If the budget instructs more than one committee, then those committees send their recommendations to the "Budget Committee of their House, and the Budget Committee packages the recommendations into a single omnibus bill. In the Senate, the reconciliation bill then gets only 20 hours of debate and amendments are limited. Only one reconciliation bill can be passed in any given year.
A reconciliation bill is a bill containing changes in law recommended pursuant to reconciliation instructions in a budget resolution. If the instructions pertain to only one committee in a chamber, that committee reports the reconciliation bill. If the instructions pertain to more than one committee, the "House Budget Committee reports an omnibus reconciliation bill, but it may not make substantive changes in the recommendations of the other committees.
The Byrd Rule is a "United States Senate rule that amends the "Congressional Budget Act of 1974 to allow Senators during the "Reconciliation Process to block legislation if it possibly would increase significantly the federal deficit "beyond a ten-year term or is otherwise an "extraneous matter" as set forth in the Budget Act. It is named after West Virginia Senator "Robert Byrd.
Reconciliation generally involves legislation that changes the budget deficit (or conceivably, the surplus). The "Byrd Rule" ("2 U.S.C. § 644, named after Democratic Senator "Robert Byrd) was adopted in 1985 and amended in 1990 to outline for which provisions reconciliation can and cannot be used. The Byrd Rule defines a provision to be "extraneous"—and therefore ineligible for reconciliation—in six cases:
Any senator may raise a procedural objection to a provision believed to be extraneous, which will then be ruled on by the "Presiding Officer, customarily on the advice of the "Senate Parliamentarian. A vote of 60 senators is required to overturn the ruling. The Presiding Officer need not necessarily follow the advice of the Parliamentarian, and the Parliamentarian can be replaced by the "Senate Majority Leader. The Vice President as President of the Senate can overrule the parliamentarian, but this has not been done since 1975. In 2001, Senate Majority Leader "Trent Lott fired Parliamentarian "Robert Dove after dissatisfaction with his rulings, replacing him with "Alan Frumin.
Reconciliation bills have included: